We all love peanut butter in my house, especially Reece’s peanut butter cups. Not overly keen on the chocolate though, sorry! These are very similar to a peanut butter cup, but homemade and – well, nicer chocolate too!
I’ve seen buckeyes around on the internet for a few years now and they are traditional in Ohio as they resemble the buckeye tree nut – basically just like a conker. They are traditionally served around Christmas time, so I thought I would have a go and bring buckeyes to the UK.
They are really easy to make and take no time at all to make a batch. I have a double recipe here, which makes practically a whole tree full, but you can halve the recipe, or halve the dough, freeze it and make some another time. They are really rich and indulgent, so you wouldn’t want to eat too many anyway, but great for a crowd.
I have used a mixture of dark and milk chocolate, but you could go all dark to offset the sugar a little if you wish.
500g smooth peanut butter – I used Skippy
120g softened butter
pinch of salt
1tsp vanilla extract
450g icing sugar – seived
200g dark 70% chocolate
100g milk chocolate
Beat the peanut butter, butter, salt and vanilla in bowl until smooth. I use my stand mixer with the paddle attachment, but this is easily done by hand.
On low speed (and with a towel wrapped around the mixer) beat in the sugar until combined. You are looking for a fairly stiff and mouldable mixture that you can easily roll into balls without getting in a mess. If it looks too sticky, add in a little more icing sugar. Similarly, if it is too dry and turns into crumbs, add another spoon of peanut butter. Its a very simple mixture, you can’t really go wrong.
Taking around a tablespoon of mixture for each one, roll into balls and place on a non stick liner, or waxed parchment. Skewer each one with a cocktail stick and chill, or freeze until firm.
When you are ready to dip, break the chocolate into small pieces and melt in the microwave, stirring the last few lumps in the residual heat to completely melt.
I like to transfer to a smaller bowl at this point as you want to dunk the balls to coat them.
Dip each ball into the molten chocolate and let the excess run back into the bowl and place back onto the non stick liner. As the peanut butter balls are so cold, the chocolate will set immediately and leave you with a nice, thin, crisp shell.
Finish coating all of the balls, tipping the bowl as the chocolate runs out and leave to set.
Pull out the cocktail sticks and leave the chocolate to completely set, before smoothing out the hole with a clean finger, or the back of a teaspoon.
I prefer them kept refrigerated, but you can place them into little paper cases in a festive box and give them as gifts.